Best versus Favorite | Restaurant Review: Osteria Francescana

Petit FoursUltimately, I have to push the rankings aside and let my heart decide.

It’s already been 10 weeks in Europe. If I can take away one important lesson from this experience, it’s to chase after what I love rather than seek after perfection. Pursuing perfection will only leave me in a puddle of disappointment.

When I was studying in New York City, The World’s 50 Best Restaurants List and Michelin Guide were my culinary scriptures. Number five is better than number ten. Three stars are better than two stars. I used to tell my friends about collecting stars and checking names off the list. But times change. I’ve decided that I can’t let intangible figures dictate where I should go.

For me, Osteria Francescana helped me reached this verdict. It was definitely one of the best meals I’ve had, but it wasn’t my favorite meals. Eleven tables in the heart of Modena tell a story of tradition in evolution. It’s truly a really great narrative that everyone should taste at least once in his or her lifetime. But in my collection of culinary memories, some tales will inevitably be consumed less than others.

The meal? The Classics Tasting Menu is a rapid three hours journey that travels through the Emilia-Romagna region. Chef Massimo Bottura speaks about cooking as if he was having an out-of-body experience every time he takes a bite of food (I’d be down for that). I’d also like to believe that I shared some of the same sensations that he underwent when I got to experience his cooking.

Tempura of Freshwater Aula with Carpione Ice Cream

For example, the tempura with carpione ice cream is such a mind-boggling start to the meal. Any conventional ice cream is cold, creamy, and sweet. However, my brain had to rewire all the circuits once I realized that the ice cream was a savory blast of freshwater fish. Man, that was fantastic.

Baccalà Mare Nostrum

The fun didn’t stop any time soon. Tasting the filet of cod with layers of caper broth and tomato water is nostalgic. I’d imagine the memory would be like if I had a barely-touched piece of wonderful white fish with a hint of lemon for the first time on a boat in the deep blue sea.

A Journey to Modena: Adriatic Eel, Polenta, Campanine Apple Jelly, Saba, Burnt Onion

Adriatic eel with polenta, apple jelly, and burnt onion particles would conjure up memories of a campfire. It’ would serve as the rustic piece of fish cooked on an open flame in the hills of Modena.

Think Green

But Mother Nature doesn’t always play in our favor. The 4th Course on the Classics titled Think Green was an assemblage of raw mushrooms, black truffle, and chlorophyll. The terms “interesting” and “delicious” do not always correspond. Then the famous five ages of parmigiano reggiano arrives next. The 30 month aged foam was my favorite while the 36 month old creamy sauce happened to be a work of art that I’d be better off observing from a distance. The compression of pasta and beans featured a humble glass of chalkiness which makes me long for the wonderful fresh yellow pasta that is flowing throughout the city of Modena.

Guinea Fowl Not Roasted

The main course was more of a delight. I was already so full from the homemade sourdough bread and endless batches of grissini (breadsticks) so I almost couldn’t finish my guinea hen prepared in two ways (but of course I did). The flesh was sprayed with the fowl’s bones enriching the dish with a hint of musky magnificence.

Guinea Fowl Not Roasted Part II

Guinea Fowl Not Roasted Part II featured chicken skin, white chocolate with garlic, dark chocolate with liver, and ice cream. This was my favorite part of the entire meal. I feel like pigs always get its fame and glory for head (or nose) to tail, but maybe it’s time for the chickens to shine.

Foie Gras Crunch with Traditional Balsamic Vinegar from Modena

Pre-dessert is always one of my favorite parts of the meal and Osteria Francescana definitely satisfied my cravings with the also-very-famous foie gras with crunchy caramelized almonds. The buttery foie is paired with a sweet balsamic from Modena. The aged vinegar cuts through the richness right away. Stellar combination.

Oops! A Broken Lemon Tart

Then, it was the lemon tart. It’s one of the few dishes that are meant to be served broken (Alinea’s Dark Chocolate is the most well known masterpiece). Sweet is often paired with savory. However, their sweet zabaglione and sour lemon was paired with capers and chili peppers. It was definitely the right way to stimulate the senses at the end of the lunch. The petit fours were also one of the best selections I’ve had all year. I still dream about the pralines and tiramisu.

Even though I was disappointed with some of the selections on the Classics tasting, I have the feeling that I’ve only scratched the surface level of Osteria Francescana’s true abilities. I do believe that I’ll be back the future.

However, it won’t be for the stars or for the rankings. Next time, the Traditions and the Sensations will be waiting for my return. Perhaps one of my future best meals here will turn into one of my favorite meals. I’m positive that my curiosity will lead me back into one of the eleven tables.


One response to “Best versus Favorite | Restaurant Review: Osteria Francescana

  1. Hey man, if you are in Italy i suggest you to go in Bergamo and try
    `la cantalupa` (da vittorio) 3 stars Michelin as well

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s